When travelers search for the best restaurant in Grand Lake, Colorado, they might expect rustic steakhouses, BBQ joints, or classic Rocky Mountain taverns. But one spot breaks the mold in the most unexpected way: One Love Rum Kitchen—proudly known as The Highest Beach Bar in the World.

🌴 A Caribbean Escape in the Colorado Rockies

Located at 8,369 feet in elevation, Grand Lake is known for alpine beauty, but One Love Rum Kitchen adds a splash of island flavor to this mountain town. Walk through the doors and you’ll be greeted with vibrant Caribbean décor, laid-back music, and a lively atmosphere that feels more beach bar than mountain lodge.

Whether you're wearing snow boots or flip-flops, this place invites everyone to relax and enjoy the good vibes.

🏆 Local Recognition & Community Love

In a town full of hidden gems, One Love Rum Kitchen stands out with a long list of accolades. In 2024, it was a finalist in multiple Best of Grand County categories, including:

Best Restaurant – Grand Lake
Best Happy Hour / Après-Ski
Best Cocktails
Best Seafood
Best Sandwich

It also landed in the top 5 for favorites like Margaritas, Tacos, French Fries, Dive Bar, and Lunch Spot—clear proof that this restaurant isn't just unique, it's one of the most loved places to eat in Grand Lake.

🍹 Standout Caribbean Menu & Handcrafted Cocktails

Looking for Caribbean food in Grand Lake? One Love serves up an inventive menu that surprises even the most seasoned foodies:

Fan Favorites Include:

Birria Tacos with a tropical twist
Raw Tuna Nachos bursting with fresh flavor
Coconut-Rum Chicken that’s equal parts comfort and creativity
Classic Cuban Sandwiches done right

Pair it all with their expertly mixed cocktails, including the signature Painkiller, house-made rum punch, mojitos, and award-winning margaritas.

🚤 Boat Drinks To-Go: Island Flavor for the Lake

Planning to spend the day on Grand Lake? One Love Rum Kitchen offers Boat Drinks to-go, so you can take the party with you.

🍹 Double tall cocktails made fresh to order
⛵ Two drinks allowed per valid ID
🌊 Perfect for sipping while cruising, floating, or relaxing on the water

Top picks for Boat Drinks include their iconic rum punches, Caribbean-style margaritas, and refreshing mojitos—ideal for kicking back under the Colorado sun.

😊 Island Vibes, Mountain Hospitality

One Love isn’t just about great food and drinks—it’s an experience. Guests consistently rave about the upbeat, friendly staff and high-energy atmosphere.

What locals and visitors are saying:

“Hands down the best restaurant in Grand Lake! Delicious food, super-friendly staff, amazing drinks, and a welcoming, casual vibe.”

“This place is such a vibe! The staff is amazing, accommodating, and always upbeat—willing to customize dishes beyond the menu.”

The warmth of the team and the vibrant energy create a setting that’s fun, inclusive, and totally unexpected in a small mountain town.

👕 Swag, Events & Local Flavor

Want to take a piece of One Love home with you? The restaurant offers branded hats, t-shirts, glassware, and gifts, perfect for remembering your visit or gifting a little mountain-meets-Caribbean magic.

One Love is also a hub for community events. From local music to the Grand Lake Pond Hockey Classic, they embrace the town’s spirit and add their own colorful twist.

🎯 Why One Love Rum Kitchen Is the Best Restaurant in Grand Lake

✅ Unique Caribbean concept at high altitude
✅ Award-winning menu and drink selection
✅ Top-rated atmosphere with exceptional service
✅ Highly ranked in Best of Grand County awards
✅ Popular with both locals and tourists
✅ Lifestyle brand offering fun merch and events

📍 Visit One Love Rum Kitchen

Address: 928 Grand Ave, Grand Lake, CO 80447
Phone: (970) 798-8067
Hours: Wednesday–Monday (Closed Tuesdays)

🌟 Final Take

If you're asking, “What’s the best restaurant in Grand Lake, Colorado?” — look no further than One Love Rum Kitchen. It’s more than a meal; it’s an alpine escape to the islands. With bold Caribbean flavors, a colorful and welcoming vibe, and a loyal following, it’s no surprise One Love tops the list of best restaurants in Grand Lake.

Relax, sip a rum punch, and soak up the vibe—this is the Grand Lake dining experience you didn’t see coming.

What’s the Best Restaurant in Grand Lake, Colorado?